New insights on the shell-crusher shark Agassiz, 1838 (Elasmobranchii, Ptychodontidae) based on the first known articulated dentition from the Upper Cretaceous of Croatia.

Unlabelled: A new lower tooth plate of from the Turonian (Upper Cretaceous) of the Dalmatian region (southern Croatia) is documented here for the first time. The specimen represents the first articulated dentition of a ptychodontid shark that has been discovered from the Balkan Peninsula and the most complete ever found for the un-cuspidate species up to now. The reconstruction of the entire lower dentition of based on this exceptionally well-preserved dentition shows a wider crushing plate than previously hypothesised with bulgy teeth limited to the central area. Even though a defined cusp is missing, the occlusal surface of the teeth is undeniably raised and bulgy in some un-cuspidate species of (e.g., ). This compels us to reconsider the use of terms such as high- and low-crowned as well as cuspidate and un-cuspidate. In addition, specimens previously assigned to dubious species (, and ) or even varieties ( var. and var. ) are reassigned here to based on a careful comparison of the type materials. The reassessment of tooth root morphologies provides indicative traits for the identification of different genera of ptychodontid sharks ( and ). The taxonomic revision presented here is crucial for securing a stable taxonomy and systematics of the shell-crushing shark , as well as of all ptychodontid sharks. The resulting updated taxonomy, together with the description and reconstruction of the new crushing plate, greatly contribute to a better understanding of one of the most enigmatic families (Ptychodontidae) of Mesozoic elasmobranchs. The detailed investigation of the new dentition of from Dalmatia is also a further step towards the discovery of Upper Cretaceous ichthyofaunas of one of the most palaeontologically important areas of the Balkan Peninsula.

Supplementary Information: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13358-024-00340-7.