Comparison of clinical independence level scores among predoctoral dental students between dental school clinic and community clinic rotation.

Objectives: The aim of this study was to compare the difference in the level of clinical independence among predoctoral dental students during their community clinic rotation with their dental school clinic rotations.

Methods: Descriptive statistics, assessment of sample normality, and T-tests were performed to present the difference in average independence scale scores for the participants in each of the clinical disciplines at dental school clinical rotations and community rotations. The relative impact of each community clinical site was assessed to compare scores assigned at varying locations by different faculty.

Results: This study analyzed 222 dental students, including 29 from International Dental Program (IDP) and 193 traditional Doctor of Dental Surgery (DDS) students. Community clinic scores showed greater variability, with significantly higher scores in diagnostics and operative dentistry compared to school clinics, where higher scores were noted in endodontics and oral surgery. IDP students scored lower than traditional DDS students in school clinics but outperformed them in community settings. Community clinic scores showed greater variation between 2023 and 2024 compared to the smaller changes observed in dental school clinic scores.

Conclusions: This study highlights the impact of clinical setting, and duration on student procedural experience and performance, suggesting that varied clinical settings can enhance students' skills and readiness for practice. It reveals differences in DDS and IDP students' experiences due to prior training and potential evaluation biases. Study findings suggested lack of significant variance in the overall scores across different evaluators in community rotations. Future research should focus on refining evaluation metrics and better prepare students for practice.