Defining a parameter to select the best radiotherapy technique in patients with right breast cancer after conservative surgery: Evaluation of high doses and risk of radio-induced second tumors to the ipsilateral lung.

Purpose: In the adjuvant right breast radiation therapy, after breast-conserving surgery, we wanted to look for a parameter that would help in the choice between the 3D-CRT or VMAT techniques, considering the risk of pneumonia to the ipsilateral lung (IL) linked to high doses. We also investigated the risk of second tumors in the IL related to the VMAT low doses.

Methods: We examined twenty-five 3D-CRT and thirty-five VMAT technique plans, between September 2022 and September 2023. We collected the MAximum Thickness of Ipsilateal Lung (MATIL) included between lateral and medial target borders for evaluating the risk of pneumonia due to the high dose (V), finally we calculated the Excess of Absolute Risk related to the second tumor risk due to the low dose.

Results: VMAT technique showed a better dose conformity than 3D-CRT. We detected a linear relationship between the V and MATIL of the IL only for the 3D-CRT technique; over a threshold value of MATIL the 3D-CRT is disadvantaged compared to the VMAT in terms of the risk of toxicity to the IL. We calculated that for every Gy more in average dose, a 12 % increase in the risk of induced cancer is expected.

Conclusions: In the adjuvant right breast RT, the MATIL is a good surrogate parameter to predict the need to use a VMAT technique to limit high doses to IL. VMAT technique, according to the IL second tumor estimated risk, seems justified.