Glial-modulating agents for the treatment of pain: a systematic review.

Preclinical research supports a critical role for nervous system glia in pain pathophysiology. This systematic review of human trials of potential glia-modulating drugs for the prevention or treatment of pain followed a predefined search strategy and protocol registration. We searched for English language, randomized, double-blind trials comparing putative glia-modulating drugs to placebo or other comparators. The primary outcomes included validated participant-reported measures of pain intensity or relief and, in studies of opioid administration, measures of opioid consumption and/or opioid-related adverse effects. Twenty-six trials (2132 participants) of glial modulators (12 minocycline, 11 pentoxifylline, and 3 ibudilast) were included. Because of clinical heterogeneity related to study drug, participant population, outcome measures, and trial design, no meta-analysis was possible. Only 6 trials reported a positive effect of the treatment (pentoxifylline-4 trials; minocycline-2 trials), whereas 11 trials reported mixed results and 9 trials reported no effect. This review does not provide convincing evidence of efficacy of current pharmacological targets of nervous system glial function for pain treatment or prevention. However, in light of ample preclinical evidence of the importance of neuroimmune signalling and glial functions in pain pathophysiology, continued strategic human research is anticipated to identify (1) drugs with maximal activity as selectively targeted glial modulators, (2) the necessary timing and duration of pharmacological glial modulation needed for pain prevention or treatment for specific injuries or pain conditions, and (3) the best design of future clinical trials of glial-targeted drugs for pain treatment and/or prevention.