Spraying or fertigation? looking for the better method in terms of the lower concentration of Pb and Ni in greenhouse cucumber.

This study was conducted to investigate the status of Lead (Pb) and Nickel (Ni) in greenhouse cucumber affected by fertigation and spraying as a factorial split plot arrangement based on a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with three replications at Soil and Water Research Institute, Karaj, Iran in 2023. The main and sub-plots were respectively fertigation and spraying that was applied in two levels [the minimum permissible concentration of these metals in granular triple super phosphate fertilizer (five ppm Pb and five ppm Ni) as the control treatment, and the maximum permissible concentration of Pb and Ni in granular triple super phosphate fertilizer (50 ppm Pb and 100 ppm Ni)]. Spraying was done in three modes (spraying leaves, leaves + fruit, and fruit). Based on the results, the highest concentration of Pb in the fruit (fruit peel + fruit flesh) (0.295 mg/kg DW) was recorded in the fertigation + spraying with the maximum permissible concentrations of Pb and Ni treatments. A general comparison between the two fertilization methods showed that the spraying method accumulated a higher concentration of Pb in the fruit (i.e., peel + flesh) than the fertigation method. The reverse of this status happened for Ni, so the fertigation method accumulated a higher concentration of Ni in the fruit (skin + flesh) compared to the spraying method. On average, the order of Pb concentration in different organs was as follows: leaf (0.765 mg/kg) > fruit peel (0.232 mg/kg) > fruit peel + flesh (0.174 mg/kg) > fruit flesh (0.129 mg/kg). This order for Ni was as follows: fruit flesh (0.597 mg/kg) > fruit peel + flesh (0.345 mg/kg) > leaf (0.3 mg/kg) > fruit peel (0.175 mg/kg). These orders show that the status of the heavy metals in plant tissues is related to the nature of the metal, the type of the organ, and the method of fertilization.