On the discrepancy between crossovers of solubility in supercritical carbon dioxide and retention in supercritical fluid chromatography.

Various crossover phenomena are immanent to supercritical fluids due to multidirectional temperature effects in highly compressible supercritical fluid media. Solubility crossover, i.e. controversial effect of temperature on solubility at different pressures, is probably the most well-known among them. A curious discrepancy in upper crossover pressure values between solubility in supercritical carbon dioxide and retention in supercritical fluid chromatography with pure CO as an eluent was unexpectedly observed for several non-polar compounds on different stationary phases. In some cases, retention crossover was found to happen at pressures almost twice as high as pressures for solubility crossover for the same compound. Retention data for three solutes with known solubility crossovers: anthracene, benzoic acid and vanillin, were collected at different pressures and temperatures for several stationary phases. The existence of upper retention crossovers, i.e. such pressure values beyond which temperature increase starts decreasing retention, were registered for all solute-sorbent combinations. Using known thermodynamic models of temperature effect on retention in supercritical fluid chromatography and on solubility in supercritical carbon dioxide, possible reasoning for the observed discrepancies is discussed. Major contribution of the balance between adsorption and partition retention mechanisms in defining retention crossover values is hypothesized.