Active Sites of Mixed-Metal Core-Shell Oxygen Evolution Reaction Catalysts: FeO Sites on Ni Cores or NiN Sites in C Shells?

Water electrolysis for clean hydrogen production requires high-activity, high-stability, and low-cost catalysts for its particularly sluggish half-reaction, the oxygen evolution reaction (OER). Currently, the most promising of such catalysts working in alkaline conditions is a core-shell nanostructure, NiFe@NC, whose Fe-doped Ni (NiFe) nanoparticles are encapsulated and interconnected by N-doped graphitic carbon (NC) layers, but the exact OER mechanism of these catalysts is still unclear, and even the location of the OER active site, either on the core side or on the shell side, is still debated. Therefore, we herein derive a plausible active-site model for each side based on various experimental evidence and density functional theory calculations and then build OER free-energy diagrams on both sides to determine the active-site location. The core-side model is an FeO-type (rather than NiO-type) active site where an Fe atom sits on Ni oxide layers grown on top of the core surface during catalyst activation, whose facile dissolution provides an explanation for the activity loss of such catalysts directly exposed to the electrolyte. The shell-side model is a NiN-type (rather than FeN-type) active site where a Ni atom is intercalated into the porphyrin-like NC site of the NC shell during catalyst synthesis. Their OER free-energy diagrams indicate that both sites require similar amounts of overpotentials, despite a complete shift in their potential-determining steps, i.e., the final O evolution from the oxophilic Fe on the core and the initial OH adsorption to the hydrophobic shell. We conclude that the major active sites are located on the core, but the NC shell not only protects the vulnerable FeO active sites on the core from the electrolyte but also provides independent active sites, owing to the N doping.