High frequency of BCP, but less CPP crystal-mediated calcification in cartilage and synovial membrane of osteoarthritis patients.

Objective: Ectopic articular calcification is a common phenomenon of osteoarthritic joints, and closely related to disease progression. Identification of the involved calcium crystal types represents an important topic in research and clinical practice. Difficulties in accurate detection and crystal type identification have led to inconsistent data on the prevalence and spatial distribution of Basic calcium phosphate (BCP) and calcium pyrophosphate (CPP) deposition.

Method: Combining multiple imaging methods including conventional radiography, histology and Raman spectroscopy, this study provides a comprehensive analysis of BCP and CPP-based calcification, its frequency and distribution in cartilage and synovial membrane samples of 92 osteoarthritis patients undergoing knee replacement surgery.

Results: Conventional radiography showed calcifications in 35% of patients. Von Kossa staining detected calcified deposits in 88% and 57% of cartilage and synovial samples, respectively. BCP crystals presented as brittle deposits on top of the cartilage surface or embedded in synovial tissue. CPP deposits appeared as larger granular needle-shaped clusters or dense circular pockets below the cartilage surface or within synovial tissue. Spectroscopic analysis detected BCP crystals in 75% of cartilage and 43% of synovial samples. CPP deposition was only detected in 18% of cartilage and 15% of synovial samples, often coinciding with BCP deposits.

Conclusion: BCP is the predominant crystal type in calcified cartilage and synovium while CPP deposition is rare, often coinciding with BCP. Distinct and qualitative information on BCP and CPP deposits in joint tissues gives rise to the speculation that different disease entities are involved that might need different treatment strategies.