Comparison of POLYTECH MESMO and Motiva Ergonomix Breast Implants With Focus on Displacement Issues: A Single Surgeon's Experience with 329 Patients.

Background: Nanotextured breast implants (classified as smooth implants by the latest ISO 14607:2018) have been described as possibly reducing major textured implant-related complications such as capsular contracture and breast implant-associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma. On the other hand, microtextured breast implants benefit from an optimal safety profile based on a much larger body of literature.

Objectives: The aim of this study was to directly compare the incidence of complications between Motiva Ergonomix (Establishment Labs Holdings, Inc., Alajuela, Costa Rica) and POLYTECH MESMO (POLYTECH Health & Aesthetics GmbH, Dieburg, Germany) breast implants, especially regarding the displacement issues that might arise after breast augmentation.

Methods: Consecutive patients who previously underwent surgery by the same physician for placement of Motiva Ergonomix and POLYTECH MESMO implants were included in this study. They were divided into 2 groups according to the type of implant. The onset of complications was assessed through survival analysis.

Results: Data were collected from 329 patients, 185 (56.2%) with POLYTECH MESMO and 144 (43.8%) with Motiva Ergonomix implants. The median follow-up was 8 months for both groups. Of the 42 women (12.8%) who experienced at least one complication, 26 belonged to the Motiva Ergonomix subgroup (P = .013). The most represented complications during this period resulted from displacement issues, with a clear prevalence of bottoming out in the Motiva Ergonomix cohort: 15 cases vs 0 cases in the POLYTECH MESMO cohort (P < .001). For 7 patients, a reoperation was required, more frequently for patients with Motiva Ergonomix implants (4.2% vs 0.5%; P = .046).

Conclusions: POLYTECH MESMO devices provided a more favorable outcome. Motiva Ergonomix devices revealed a concerning incidence of displacement issues during the first postsurgery years, with no advantage over other major complications.