A Kleinian appreciation of the Ego and the Id (1923-2023).

Int J Psychoanal

Member Emeritus, Société Psychanalytique de Monttréal (Canadian Psychoanalytic Society), Université de Montréal, Montreal, QC, Canada.

Published: December 2023

I divide this paper into three parts. First, I discuss Freud's ideas about repression and the unconscious sense of guilt in order to compare them with Klein's view that we disown uncomfortable facts through a process of splitting and projection, leading to a paranoid defence against guilt. Second, I describe Klein's struggle to understand the origin and the severity of the primitive super-ego which was so prominent in her child patients. She considered that an important aim of analysis was to moderate the severity of the super-ego to create a more humane inner world. Finally, I will elaborate on her view, as well as Freud's, that some of the primitive terrifying objects that lie buried deep in the unconscious are fixed and unmodifiable. I will use some ideas from Ron Britton to suggest that instead of trying to modify or get rid of these persecuting figures, it might be possible to stand up to them and to emancipate the ego from the tyranny of the super-ego.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00207578.2023.2277016DOI Listing

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

kleinian appreciation
4
appreciation ego
4
ego 1923-2023
4
1923-2023 divide
4
divide paper
4
paper three
4
three parts
4
parts discuss
4
discuss freud's
4
freud's ideas
4

Similar Publications

A Kleinian appreciation of the Ego and the Id (1923-2023).

Int J Psychoanal

December 2023

Member Emeritus, Société Psychanalytique de Monttréal (Canadian Psychoanalytic Society), Université de Montréal, Montreal, QC, Canada.

I divide this paper into three parts. First, I discuss Freud's ideas about repression and the unconscious sense of guilt in order to compare them with Klein's view that we disown uncomfortable facts through a process of splitting and projection, leading to a paranoid defence against guilt. Second, I describe Klein's struggle to understand the origin and the severity of the primitive super-ego which was so prominent in her child patients.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

The observation that incompatibility with conscience initiates deployment of defense goes back to Freud's conceptualization of the "incompatible idea" put forward in Studies on Hysteria. In this view, consciousness itself, insofar as it gives rise to painful affect resulting from conflict with the conscience, is the cornerstone for dynamic thinking, first as regards repression of traumatic memory and later for dynamic thinking generally. Subsequent discoveries about the conscience tended to give rise to pars pro toto thinking in which the new discovery replaced rather than added to the basic notion of conscience.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?

Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!