[Functionality and everyday suitability of commercially wristwear products for frail older people - a comparative product testing].

Background And Aim: There is a wide range of smartwatches and emergency watches on the market that are specifically designed for older people. The products are freely available, which is why there is an urgent need for information about the reliability and functionality of the products among potential users, but also health professionals and decision-makers. As part of a systematic product comparison test, the functionality and quality of seven smartwatches were investigated.

Method: Four watches for seniors, one watch for adults and two watches for children, but with comparable functionalities, were included in the test. For the test, real-life situations were simulated and, in addition to emergency calls, GPS tracking, fall detection and geofencing, the battery life, call quality, stability/robustness of the products and service/support were evaluated. From the total number of points, a grade was determined based on the German school grading system (1 = very good to 6 = insufficient).

Results: All smartwatches evaluated were rated at least "3-satisfactory". The two best-rated watches received a score of 1.8. The differences were particularly evident in the emergency call functionality, battery life, precision of the tracking function, and service/support. The call quality, with one exception, and the stability/robustness were consistently rated as "1-very good". Three watches in the test were able to detect falls with variable results.

Conclusion: The functionality and usability of the tested products differed considerably. A focus on a few main functions can even provide added value for older, frail people. Continuous comparative testing of products for this target group with new and updated products is desirable.