Percentage of negative urine drug screens as a clinically meaningful endpoint for RCTs evaluating treatment for cocaine use.

Background: This study examined a threshold based on the percentage of cocaine-negative (CN) urine drug screens (UDS) collected during treatment as a potential meaningful endpoint for clinical trials. We hypothesized that individuals providing at least 75% CN UDS would have better long-term outcomes than those providing less than 75% CN UDS.

Methods: Two separate pooled datasets of randomized clinical trials conducted at different institutions were used for analyses: one composed of eight trials (N = 760) and the other composed of three trials (N = 416), all evaluating behavioral and/or pharmacological treatments for cocaine use. UDS were collected at least once per week (up to three times per week) during the 8- or 12-week treatment period across all trials, with substance use and psychosocial functioning measured up to 12 months following treatment. Chi-squares and ANOVAs compared within-treatment and follow-up outcomes between the groups.

Results: Compared to those who did not achieve the threshold, participants who achieved the 75%-CN threshold were retained in treatment longer and had a longer period of continuous abstinence, and were more likely to report problem-free functioning. Additionally, participants who achieved the 75%-CN threshold were more likely to report sustained abstinence and better psychosocial functioning throughout a follow-up period up to 12 months than those who did not achieve the threshold.

Conclusions: A threshold of 75%-CN UDS is associated with short- and long-term clinical benefits. Future clinical trials may consider this a meaningful threshold for defining treatment responders.