Higher intra-operative narcotic requirements and weakness with quadratus lumborum compared to paravertebral nerve block for total hip arthroplasty.

Background: This was a prospective single-blinded study comparing the peri-operative opioid consumption and motor weakness for patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty (THA) with either a Quadratus Lumborum Type 3 Nerve Block (QLB) or a Paravertebral Nerve Block (PVB).

Methods: A consecutive cohort of patients undergoing elective anterior approach (AA) THA by a single high-volume surgeon were randomly assigned an anesthesiologist by the charge anesthesiologist. One anesthesiologist performed all QLBs, and the other six anesthesiologists performed the PVBs. Pertinent data include prospectively collected qualitative surveys from blinded medical personnel, floor nurses, and physical therapists as well as demographic information and post-operative complications.

Results: Overall, 160 patients were included in the study divided equally between the QLB and PVB groups. The QLB group had a statistically higher peri-operative narcotic use (p < 0.001), greater intra-operative peak systolic blood pressure (p < 0.001) and respiratory rate (p < 0.001), and higher incidence of post-operative lower extremity muscle weakness (p = 0.040). There were no statistical group differences for floor narcotic use, post-operative hemoglobin levels or hospital length of stay.

Conclusion: The QLB required greater intraoperative narcotic use and resulted in greater post-operative weakness, however provided nearly equal post-operative pain management and did not adversely affect rapid discharge success.

Level Of Evidence: III, Non-randomized controlled cohort/follow-up study.