Clinical and Analytic Accuracy of Simultaneously Acquired Hemoglobin Measurements: A Multi-Institution Cohort Study to Minimize Redundant Laboratory Usage.

Objectives: Frequent diagnostic blood sampling contributes to anemia among critically ill children. Reducing duplicative hemoglobin testing while maintaining clinical accuracy can improve patient care efficacy. The objective of this study was to determine the analytical and clinical accuracy of simultaneously acquired hemoglobin measurements with different methods.

Design: Retrospective cohort study.

Setting: Two U.S. children's hospitals.

Patients: Children (< 18 yr old) admitted to the PICU.

Interventions: None.

Measurements And Main Results: We identified hemoglobin results from complete blood count (CBC) panels paired with blood gas (BG) panels and point-of-care (POC) devices. We estimated analytic accuracy by comparing hemoglobin distributions, correlation coefficients, and Bland-Altman bias. We measured clinical accuracy with error grid analysis and defined mismatch zones as low, medium, or high risk-based on deviance from unity and risk of therapeutic error. We calculated pairwise agreement to a binary decision to transfuse based on a hemoglobin value. Our cohort includes 49,004 ICU admissions from 29,926 patients, resulting in 85,757 CBC-BG hemoglobin pairs. BG hemoglobin was significantly higher (mean bias, 0.43-0.58 g/dL) than CBC hemoglobin with similar Pearson correlation ( R2 ) (0.90-0.91). POC hemoglobin was also significantly higher, but of lower magnitude (mean bias, 0.14 g/dL). Error grid analysis revealed only 78 (< 0.1%) CBC-BG hemoglobin pairs in the high-risk zone. For CBC-BG hemoglobin pairs, at a BG hemoglobin cutoff of greater than 8.0 g/dL, the "number needed to miss" a CBC hemoglobin less than 7 g/dL was 275 and 474 at each institution, respectively.

Conclusions: In this pragmatic two-institution cohort of greater than 29,000 patients, we show similar clinical and analytic accuracy of CBC and BG hemoglobin. Although BG hemoglobin values are higher than CBC hemoglobin values, the small magnitude is unlikely to be clinically significant. Application of these findings may reduce duplicative testing and decrease anemia among critically ill children.