Comparison of mild physiological effects of surgical masks and N95 respirators over 60 min at rest.

Dead-space-associated rebreathing of expired air and heat trapping with use of surgical masks and N95 respirators may underlie anecdotal reports of adverse symptoms associated with medical face barriers. Limited data exist directly comparing the physiological effects of masks and respirators at rest. We assessed the short-term physiological effects of both barrier types over 60 min at rest, including face microclimate temperature, end-tidal gases, and venous blood acid-base variables. We recruited 34 participants into two trials: surgical masks ( = 17) and N95 respirators ( = 17). In a seated position, participants underwent a 10-min baseline without a barrier and then wore a standardized surgical mask or dome-shaped N95 respirator for 60 min, followed by a 10-min washout. We instrumented healthy human participants with a peripheral pulse oximeter ([Formula: see text]) and a nasal cannula connected to a dual gas analyzer for measurement of the pressure of end-tidal [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text], with an associated temperature probe for face microclimate temperature. Venous (v) blood samples were obtained at baseline and following 60-min mask/respirator wearing to assess [Formula: see text], [HCO]v and pHv. Compared with baseline during/following 60 min, temperature, [Formula: see text], [Formula: see text], and [HCO]v were mildly but significantly higher, and [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] were significantly lower, but [Formula: see text] was unaffected. The magnitude of effects was similar between barrier types. Temperature and [Formula: see text] returned to baseline levels within 1-2 min following removal of the barrier. These mild physiological effects may underlie reports of qualitative symptoms while wearing masks or respirators. However, the magnitudes were mild, not physiologically relevant and reversed immediately with the removal of the barrier. Anecdotal reports suggest mild physiological effects of wearing surgical masks and/or N95 respirators, including heat trapping and rebreathing of expired air. There are limited data directly comparing the physiological effects of wearing medical barriers at rest. We found that the time course and magnitude of changes to face microclimate temperature, end-tidal gases, and venous blood gases and acid-base variables were mild in magnitude, not physiologically relevant, equivalent between barrier types, and immediately reversible on removal.