The efficacy of a range of hygiene measures for boot cleaning to protect natural vegetation from Phytophthora cinnamomi.

Phytophthora cinnamomi is an oomycete found in the soil and capable of invading the roots of a wide range of host plants globally, potentially killing them and affecting the ecosystems they inhabit. This pathogen is often inadvertently dispersed in natural vegetation on the footwear of humans. A range of equipment is often provided or recommended to be carried for cleaning footwear in places where P. cinnamomi poses a threat to biodiversity. These are typically a brush for mechanically removing soil and/or a disinfectant for killing the pathogen. Despite their widespread use, to our knowledge, the majority of hygiene measures have not been experimentally tested for their efficacy. In the current study, we tested whether two types of brush and the two most widely used disinfectants (70% methylated spirits and benzalkonium chloride) were effective in removing the pathogen from boots. We tested the brushes and disinfectants in two soil types and two moisture levels. All hygiene measures were found to be better than doing nothing, although some were only effective with sandy or dry soils. Benzalkonium chloride was largely ineffective as a spray but highly effective when used in a footbath. Brushing did not improve cleaning when used with 70% methylated spirits. None of the hygiene measures was completely effective for cleaning boots that had been in wet loamy soil. Our findings have important implications for management of this threat because some recommended hygiene practices are not doing what they claim.