Editorial Commentary: Diagnosis, Treatment, Rehabilitation and Return to Sport After Ulnar Collateral Ligament Injury: Agreement Does not Equal Consensus.

Tommy John surgical reconstruction for ulnar collateral ligament injuries was first described by Frank Jobe in 1974. Although he estimated the chance for successful return very low, John, famous baseball pitcher, was able to return to play for another 14 years. Modern techniques and better understanding of anatomy and biomechanics have now resulted in a return-to-play rate of more than 80%. Ulnar collateral ligament injuries occur mainly in overhead athletes. Generally, partial tears can be treated nonoperatively, but in baseball pitchers, success rates are less than 50%. Complete tears often require surgery. Primary repair or reconstruction are feasible options, and the choice will depend not only on the clinical scenario, but also the surgeon. Unfortunately, the current evidence is not convincing, and a recent expert consensus study exploring diagnosis, treatment options, rehabilitation, and return to sports showed agreement among the experts, but not necessarily a consensus.