A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Intra-Operative Surgical Site Sampling: Culture versus Culture-Independent Techniques in Predicting Downstream Surgical Site Infection.

Surgical site infection remains a significant cause of morbidity and mortality. Traditionally, the causation has been inferred from the organism(s) detected in the post-operative setting. However, the intra-operative surgical site and the bacteria it harbors have been scarcely studied. Compared with culture-dependent methods, the development of genomic technology provides a new sensitive tool that could aid in characterizing the bacteria within the surgical site. The purpose of this literature review is to establish if there is a predictive role of sampling the intra-operative surgical site. A systematic literature review was conducted identifying relevant literature reporting on studies that sampled the intra-operative surgical site of any specialty, using either traditional culture or a culture-independent genomic sequencing-based technique and correlation with infection was attempted. The review identified studies between 1959 and 2021 in MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane. The initial search identified 7,835 articles; 36 remained after screening. Thirty-one articles focused on culture-dependent techniques, five on culture-independent. Subgroup meta-analysis demonstrates that a positive intra-operative culture carries a risk of downstream infection with an odds ratio of 8.6, however limited by a high false-positive and inability to correlate the intra-operative culture with the post-operative infection. In contrast, culture-independent studies through genomic sequencing are not predictive but suggest that the surgical incision is a complex microbial community with a shift toward dysbiosis in certain patients. The intra-operative surgical site clearly harbors bacteria. Both techniques give rise to separate explanations underpinning the role of bacteria in surgical site infection. It is possible there is a more complex dynamic community within the incision that makes a patient susceptible to infection. Characterizing this microbial community in large scale studies, including patients with infections may enhance our ability to predict and prevent incisional surgical site infections in patients undergoing surgical procedures.