The role of vestibular cold caloric tests in the presence of spontaneous nystagmus.

Objective: The bithermal caloric test is commonly used to detect a canal paresis. However, in case of spontaneous nystagmus, this procedure can provide results of non-univocal interpretation. On the other hand, confirming the presence of a unilateral vestibular deficit can help to differentiate between central and a peripheral vestibular involvement.

Methods: We studied 78 patients suffering from acute vertigo and showing spontaneous horizontal unidirectional nystagmus. All patients were submitted to bithermal caloric tests, and the results were compared with those obtained using a monothermal (cold) caloric test.

Results: We demonstrate the congruence between the bithermal and monothermal (cold) caloric test through mathematical analysis of the results of both tests in patients with acute vertigo and spontaneous nystagmus.

Conclusions: We propose to perform the caloric test in the presence of a spontaneous nystagmus using a monothermal cold assuming that the prevalence of the response to the cold irrigation on the side towards which the nystagmus beats is a sign of the presence of pathological unilateral weakness and therefore more likely peripheral in its origin.