Distinctions and blurred boundaries between qualitative approaches and public and patient involvement (PPI) in research.

Int J Speech Lang Pathol

National Research Officer, National Research Office, Tusla Child and Family Agency, Dublin, Ireland.

Published: October 2022

: International health and social care policy increasingly draws on stakeholder experiences and opinions. The distinctions between various approaches to researching "insider" perspectives are contentious. This article explores features (e.g. philosophy, ethics, and power dynamics) of qualitative approaches and public and patient involvement (PPI) in communication disorder research and explicates the blurred boundaries between them.: We use two case studies involving PPI contributors with aphasia - an Irish mixed methodologies study and a Danish qualitative study - to illustrate PPI in research and thus demonstrate how researchers can bridge the gap between theoretical considerations and research implementation: There are important distinctions between PPI in research and qualitative approaches (e.g. origins, roles, and reimbursement) and many blurred boundaries (e.g. inclusion, openness to mutual learning and "insider" perspectives). A key difference is that PPI contributors take an active role at project level and more flexibility in roles is required in PPI research. These flexible and varied roles reflect the shared decision-making powers between lay and professional researchers.: PPI can add innovation to qualitative and mixed methods communication disorder research as illustrated in both case studies. However, researchers wishing to include PPI must embrace and respond to the evolving and flexible nature of PPI relationships and processes. Flexibility, negotiation and continuous reflection on methodological approaches, power dynamics, roles and co-created knowledge will impact and transform the field of research in communication disorders.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17549507.2022.2075465DOI Listing

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

blurred boundaries
12
qualitative approaches
12
ppi
10
approaches public
8
public patient
8
patient involvement
8
involvement ppi
8
"insider" perspectives
8
power dynamics
8
communication disorder
8

Similar Publications

Extracting fragmented cropland is essential for effective cropland management and sustainable agricultural development. However, extracting fragmented cropland presents significant challenges due to its irregular and blurred boundaries, as well as the diversity in crop types and distribution. Deep learning methods are widely used for land cover classification.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Background: Genetic testing has traditionally been divided into molecular genetics and cytogenetics, originally driven by the use of different assays and their associated limitations. Cytogenetic technologies such as karyotyping, fluorescent in situ hybridization or chromosomal microarrays are used to detect large "megabase level" copy number variants and other structural variants such as inversions or translocations. In contrast, molecular methodologies are heavily biased toward subgenic "small variants" such as single nucleotide variants, insertions/deletions, and targeted detection of intragenic, exon level deletions or duplications.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Detection and teeth segmentation from X-rays, aiding healthcare professionals in accurately determining the shape and growth trends of teeth. However, small dataset sizes due to patient privacy, high noise, and blurred boundaries between periodontal tissue and teeth pose challenges to the models' transportability and generalizability, making them prone to overfitting. To address these issues, we propose a novel model, named Grouped Attention and Cross-Layer Fusion Network (GCNet).

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Rationale & Objective: Dialysis patient care technicians (PCTs) provide essential, frontline care for patients receiving in-center hemodialysis. We qualitatively explored perceptions of the PCT job role, responsibilities, and training among current PCTs, non-PCT dialysis staff, and patients receiving hemodialysis.

Study Design: Focus group study.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

The social life of creative methods: Filmmaking, fabulation and recovery.

Br J Sociol

December 2024

Artist in Residence, Centre for Health, Arts, Society and the Environment (CHASE), University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.

In this article we consider the theoretical and methodological implications of Deleuzian fabulation for research on recovery from drugs and alcohol as an alternative way of making and doing methods in sociology. The article draws on data produced as part of an ongoing interdisciplinary research collaboration, begun in 2019, with the visual artist and filmmaker Melanie Manchot, social scientists Nicole Vitellone and Lena Theodoropoulou, and people in recovery from drugs and alcohol engaged in the production of Manchot's first feature film STEPHEN. This project attends to the methodological practice of filmmaking as a way of thinking with and alongside colleagues from divergent disciplines about the role of methods, concepts and practices for confronting and resisting processes of stigmatisation.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?

Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!