Calcium chloride dihydrate supplementation at ICSI improves fertilization and pregnancy rates in patients with previous low fertilization: a retrospective paired treatment cycle study.

Purpose: To determine if 5mM calcium chloride dihydrate supplementation of the Polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) media at the time of ICSI (ICSI-Ca) improves fertilization, utilization, and clinical pregnancy rates compared to ICSI alone, particularly in patients with a history of low fertilization (< 50%).

Methods: Retrospective study between 2016 and 2021 at Monash IVF Victoria on a paired cohort of patients (n = 178 patients) where an ICSI cycle was analyzed coupled with the subsequent ICSI-Ca cycle. The paired cohort was further subdivided into a low-fertilization cohort (< 50% fertilization on previous cycles: n = 66 patients) compared to the remaining patients with fertilization ≥ 50% (n = 122). Exclusion criteria included donor cycles, PGT patients, surgical sperm retrieval, women ≥ 45 years old, patients with > 6 cycles, and patients with ≤ 5 inseminated oocytes.

Results: Calcium supplementation significantly increased both fertilization (28.8% ICSI vs 49.7% ICSI-Ca, P < 0.0001) and clinical pregnancy rate (4.9% ICSI vs 25.0% ICSI-Ca: P < 0.05) in the low-fertilization cohort but not in the normal-fertilization cohort. Interestingly, utilization rate significantly increased in the normal-fertilization cohort (32.6% ICSI vs ICSI-Ca: 44.9%, P < 0.01) but not in the low-fertilization cohort, although the number of embryos utilized per patient after ICSI-Ca increased in both groups.

Conclusion: Calcium supplementation does not appear to be a detrimental addition to ICSI and may improve IVF outcomes, particularly for patients with a history of low fertilization. Further investigations including prospective case-matched studies or a RCT are required to confirm these findings.