Clinical evaluation of grayscale and linear scale hepatorenal indices for fatty liver quantification: a prospective study of a native Chinese population.

Background And Aims: Hepato-renal index (HRI) has been investigated extensively in various clinical studies. New linear scale HRI (LS-HRI) is proposed as an alternative to conventional grayscale HRI (GS-HRI) that suffers from lack of a widely accepted cut-off value for differentiation of fatty from normal livers. To investigate the diagnostic performance of conventional GS-HRI and new LS-HRI for a relatively large Chinese population with NAFLD using a well-established ultrasonographic fatty liver indicator (US-FLI) as the reference standard for steatosis grades.

Materials And Methods: A total of 106 patients with various stages of NAFLD were prospectively enrolled. All ultrasound images for these patients were first acquired by a highly experienced ultrasound doctor and their US-FLI scores then obtained by the same doctor. Both GS-HRI and LS-HRI values were measured off-line by two additional ultrasound doctors. Four steatosis grades were determined from US-FLI scores for steatosis detection and staging.

Results: Inter-observer agreements for both GS-HRI and LS-HRI were excellent with the respective concordance correlation coefficient (CCC) of 0.900 for GS-HRI and 0.822 for LS-HRI. A linear correlation to US-FLI for LS-HRI (R = 0.74) was substantially superior to that for GS-HRI (R = 0.46). LS-HRI had a sensitivity of 85.9% and a specificity of 96.3% to differentiate steatosis from the normal liver (AUROC: 95.5%) while GS-HRI had a sensitivity of 85.9% and a specificity of 92.6% to distinguish steatosis from the normal liver (AUROC: 94.7%).

Conclusions: Both GS-HRI and LS-HRI measurements are reproducible between two ultrasonographic clinicians and are evidently effective for steatosis detection.