Advantages of Quantitative Analysis of Depth-Dependent Fluorescence Quenching: Case Study of BAX.

Dynamic disorder of the lipid bilayer presents a challenge for establishing structure-function relationships in membrane proteins, especially to those that insert by refolding from soluble states, e.g., bacterial toxins and Bcl-2 apoptotic regulators. Because many high-resolution structural techniques cannot be easily applied to such systems, methods like depth-dependent fluorescence quenching gained prominence. Over three decades ago, Prof. Erwin London and his co-workers revolutionized the studies of membrane protein insertion by introducing a quantitative approach to the analysis of membrane quenching data and inspired many researchers to continue this work. Here, we illustrate how the application of the quantitative analysis yields new insights into previously published results. We have used the method of distribution analysis (DA) to calculate the precise immersion depth of NBD fluorophores selectively attached to various single-cysteine mutants of the apoptotic factor BAX from quenching data obtained with a series of spin-labeled lipids. The original qualitative analysis interpreted the higher quenching determined for shallower probes in positions flanking the helix 9 of BAX as evidence of a transmembrane helix 9 topology. The quantitative DA, however, revealed that a transmembrane topology of helix 9 of BAX is unlikely, as it would require labeling sites that are only 15 residues apart in a helical conformation to be separated by a transverse distance of over 45 Å.