Comparison of DNA/RNA yield and integrity between PMAP36-mediated and other bacterial lysis methods.

Currently, several methods are available for the isolation of bacterial DNA and RNA. However, the diversity and complexity of cell envelope structures limit their efficiency depending on the target bacterial species. In this study, we compared the differences in yield and integrity of RNA prepared from four gram-negative and six gram-positive bacterial species using bead-beating, bacteriolytic protein, and PMAP36-vortexing methods. Similarly, we also compared the efficiency of DNA extraction from Staphylococcus aureus. Physical disruption of bacterial cells showed versatility in breaking cells against all tested species; however, a decrease in the integrity of isolated DNA and RNA was observed. Among membranolytic proteins, PMAP36 showed the most promising results, in terms of both the yield and integrity of the prepared nucleic acids. Our results show that each method has inherent advantages and disadvantages depending on its application. Therefore, the characteristics of each method and target species should be considered before the extraction of bacterial DNA and RNA.