Comparing clinical outcomes between extended curettage and wide resection in Enneking stage 3 giant cell tumor of bone.

Purpose: Our objectives were (1) to compare the recurrence, metastases, and complication rates of patients with Enneking stage 3 GCTB who underwent extended curettage vs wide resection and (2) examine the factors which might influence surgical options for each patient.

Methods: We retrospectively reviewed the records of patients with Enneking stage 3 GCTB from January 2006-December 2015. Extended curettage was performed in patients in whom there was a moderate expansile lesion, minimal/no articular cartilage damage, and less than 50% of cortical deformation compared to its circumference from a CT scan/MRI. The percentages of cortical deformation were collected. Surgical complications, recurrence, and metastatic rates were analyzed.

Results: There were 28 extended curettage and 41 wide resections. The mean percentages of cortical deformation compared to circumference were 52.6% (range, 23.9-81.9%) and 91.6% (range, 52.1-100%)(P < 0.01) for the curettage and wide resection groups, respectively. There were three recurrences, 2/28 (7.1%) from the curettage group and 1/41 (2.4%) from the resection group (P = 0.56). There were no cases of pulmonary metastasis. There were two complications in the curettage group and five complications in the resection group.

Conclusion: Both extended curettage and wide resection are useful methods to treat Enneking stage 3 GCTB. Extended curettage with proper technique is a viable option showing no difference in local recurrence rate and potentially fewer complications. Preference to do extended curettage in patients in whom when the articular cartilage has minimal or no destruction, a moderate expansile lesion and the cortical deformation is less than 50% of the circumference.