Was it necessary to change the therapeutic range of topiramate?

Aims: The Norwegian Association for Clinical Pharmacology in their National Guidelines decreased the therapeutic range (TR) of topiramate (TPM) from 5-20 mg/L to 2-10 mg/L. The objective of this study is to ascertain which TR produces better clinical outcomes.

Methods: The data sources were request forms for routine therapeutic drug monitoring (TDM) of TPM. Concentration dependent adverse drug reactions (ADRs) were evaluated in 1721 samples taken pre-dose. Seizure frequency analysis was performed in 294 samples of monotherapy. Statistical analysis was performed using Prism 5.0, GraphPad Instatt: One-way ANOVA with Bonferroni correction for median plasma level (PL) and χ -test with Bonferroni correction for seizure frequency and for distribution of PL according to TR 5-20 mg/L and intervals <2, 2-5, 5-10, 10-20, >20 mg/L.

Results: Better seizure control was found in children both in the whole cohort (without seizure 49% vs 37% adults), as well as in monotherapy (56% vs 44%), in children with PL 5-20 mg/L vs <5 mg/L (65% vs 44%) and in children with PL 5-10 mg/L vs <2 mg/L (63 vs 14%). PL in seizure-free patients did not differ from those with seizure. Seizure control was poorer in the period 2003-2005 compared to 2006-2011. ADRs reported in 38 samples (2.8%) were not related to PL.

Conclusions: Change of TR is not recommended.