Early Surgical Treatment of Both Tumor and Fracture in Patients With Enchondroma of the Hand Combined With Pathologic Fracture.

Purpose: The aims of this study were to evaluate the degree of cortical thinning and the tumor area in simple radiographs in patients with enchondroma of the hand combined with pathologic fracture and to determine the surgical outcome of simultaneous tumor curettage and internal fixation of fracture.

Methods: We enrolled 23 bone lesions of 21 patients diagnosed with enchondroma of the hand. Of them, 9 bone lesions of 8 patients had pathologic fracture. We evaluated the degree of cortical thinning and tumor area in simple radiographs and compared them between patients with and without pathologic fracture. For patients with pathologic fracture, we performed curettage of the tumor through the fracture site and fixed the fracture using K-wires. We then evaluated the clinical outcome of these patients using the visual analog scale to measure pain intensity and Takigawa's criteria 1 year after surgery.

Results: There was a significant difference in the degree of cortical thinning between the 2 groups (P < 0.001); however, there was no significant difference in the percentage of tumor area (P = 0.259). The average time from surgery to bony union was 8.5 weeks in patients with pathologic fracture. The patients reported that they could return to their previous activities of daily living within 12 weeks of surgery. The average visual analog scale score was 0.6 at 1 year after surgery, and 6 patients were graded as excellent and 2 as good according to Takigawa's criteria.

Conclusions: Cortical thinning seems to be related to pathologic fracture. Our scoring system for cortical thinning may be helpful in evaluating the risk for pathologic fracture. Early 1-stage surgical treatment for pathologic hand fracture with enchondroma is a very useful method with satisfactory outcomes that could shorten the treatment period.