Renal comorbidities in collapsing variant focal segmental glomerulosclerosis: more than a coincidence?

Background: Collapsing focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) has various underlying etiologies and often leads to renal failure. The impact of biopsy-proven renal comorbidities in promoting collapsing glomerulopathy (CG) has not been systematically evaluated in large comparative studies. Those data are reported here.

Methods: Biopsies with the initial diagnosis of CG in native (n = 321) or transplant kidneys (n = 30) were identified in the University of North Carolina nephropathology database (1 January 2011 to 1 January 2016). Two cohorts were defined: 'sole' CG without and 'accompanied' CG with significant morphologic renal comorbidities. Tip-variant FSGS (T-FSGS) and time-matched biopsies served as control cohorts for comparative analyses.

Results: CG was significantly more common in native (4.4%) and transplant biopsies (4.1%) compared with T-FSGS (0.7 and <0.1%, respectively, difference versus CG P < 0.01). 'Associated' disease was significantly more common in CG (native: 151/321; 47.0%, transplant: 21/30; 70%, P < 0.05) versus T-FSGS (native: 14/51; 27.5%, transplant: exceptional; all differences versus CG P < 0.05). In native biopsies with 'accompanied' CG but not in control groups, stenosing vasculopathies including thrombotic microangiopathies were significantly more prevalent (P < 0.01). In transplants, the high incidence of 'accompanied' CG was linked to de novo diseases, mainly rejection and vascular injury. In native kidneys, membranous glomerulopathies were prevalent in 'accompanied' T-FSGS (36%) and CG (14%) (difference versus time-matched controls P < 0.01 and P < 0.05, respectively); they were uncommon in transplants.

Conclusions: CG but not T-FSGS shows a high rate of comorbidities, with prominent vasculopathies presumably driving 'ischemic' CG-specific glomerular injury and also the disease course. These findings facilitate future studies into therapy, prognosis and reversibility of 'accompanied' CG.