Loading of the lumbar spine during transition from standing to sitting: effect of fusion versus motion preservation at L4-L5 and L5-S1.

Background Context: Transition from standing to sitting significantly decreases lumbar lordosis with the greatest lordosis-loss occurring at L4-S1. Fusing L4-S1 eliminates motion and thus the proximal mobile segments maybe recruited during transition from standing to sitting to compensate for the loss of L4-S1 mobility. This may subject proximal segments to supra-physiologic flexion loading.

Purpose: Assess effects of instrumented fusion versus motion preservation at L4-L5 and L5-S1 on lumbar spine loads and proximal segment motions during transition from standing to sitting.

Study Design: Biomechanical study using human thoracolumbar spine specimens.

Methods: A novel laboratory model was used to simulate lumbosacral alignment changes caused by a person's transition from standing to sitting in eight T10-sacrum spine specimens. The sacrum was tilted in the sagittal plane while constraining anterior-posterior translation of T10. Continuous loading-data and segmental motion-data were collected over a range of sacral slope values, which represented transition from standing to different sitting postures. We compared different constructs involving fusions and motion preserving prostheses across L4-S1.

Results: After L4-S1 fusion, the sacrum could not be tilted as far posteriorly compared to the intact spine for the same applied moment (p<.001). For the same reduction in sacral slope, L4-S1 fusion induced 2.9 times the flexion moment in the lumbar spine and required 2.4 times the flexion motion of the proximal segments as the intact condition (p<.001). Conversely, motion preservation at L4-S1 restored lumbar spine loads and proximal segment motions to intact specimen levels during transition from standing to sitting.

Conclusions: In general, sitting requires lower lumbar segments to undergo flexion, thereby increasing load on the lumbar disks. L4-S1 fusion induced greater moments and increased flexion of proximal segments to attain a comparable seated posture. Motion preservation using a total joint replacement prosthesis at L4-S1 restored the lumbar spine loads and proximal segment motion to intact specimen levels during transition from standing to sitting.

Clinical Significance: After L4-S1 fusion, increased proximal segment loading during sitting may cause discomfort in some patients and may lead to junctional breakdown over time. Preserving motion at L4-S1 may improve patient comfort and function during activities of daily living, and potentially decrease the need for adjacent level surgery.