The "completely randomised" and the "randomised block" are the only experimental designs suitable for widespread use in pre-clinical research.

Sci Rep

c/o The Medical Research Council, 2nd. floor, David Phillips Building, Polaris House, North Star Av., Swindon, Wiltshire, SN2 1FL, UK.

Published: October 2020

Too many pre-clinical experiments are giving results which cannot be reproduced. This may be because the experiments are incorrectly designed. In "Completely randomized" (CR) and "Randomised block" (RB) experimental designs, both the assignment of treatments to experimental subjects and the order in which the experiment is done, are randomly determined. These designs have been used successfully in agricultural and industrial research and in clinical trials for nearly a century without excessive levels of irreproducibility. They must also be used in pre-clinical research if the excessive level of irreproducibility is to be eliminated. A survey of 100 papers involving mice and rats was used to determine whether scientists had used the CR or RB designs. The papers were assigned to three categories "Design acceptable", "Randomised to treatment groups", so of doubtful validity, or "Room for improvement". Only 32 ± 4.7% of the papers fell into the first group, although none of them actually named either the CR or RB design. If the current high level of irreproducibility is to be eliminated, it is essential that scientists engaged in pre-clinical research use "Completely randomised" (CR), "Randomised block" (RB), or one of the more specialised named experimental designs described in textbooks on the subject.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7567855PMC
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-74538-3DOI Listing

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

"randomised block"
12
experimental designs
12
"completely randomised"
8
randomised" "randomised
8
block" experimental
8
level irreproducibility
8
irreproducibility eliminated
8
designs
5
"randomised
4
experimental
4

Similar Publications

The large pine weevil ( L.) is a major pest in European and Asian coniferous forests, particularly in managed plantations where clear-felling practices create ideal conditions for its population growth. Traditional management practices involving synthetic insecticides have limited efficacy in terms of reducing pest populations and pose environmental risks.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Objectives: To evaluate the impact of pharmaceutical care on the number of readmissions and visits to the emergency department due to heart failure 30 days after hospital discharge, based on a programme of continuous pharmaceutical care throughout the care process, and to assess the differences between the control and intervention groups at 90 days after discharge (number of readmissions and visits to the emergency department, time from discharge to new readmission or visit to the emergency department).

Methods: A single-centre experimental longitudinal prospective open and parallel-group study with balanced randomisation (1:1) was carried out in a tertiary hospital in Spain. Patients with a diagnosis of primary or decompensated heart failure admitted to the Cardiology Service or the Heart Failure and Vascular Risk Unit were recruited between March 2019 and November 2021 and randomly assigned, using a randomised block model, to the control (standard care) or intervention (continuing care model) groups.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

The present study aimed to confirm the previously reported 'recovery' effect to a challenging diet (CD) of a Lactobacilli-based probiotic (Pro) and its derived postbiotic (Post) in broilers. Identical diet compositions were used, and observations were extended to a second CD diet. A completely randomised block design of 2 × 3 treatment groups with two CDs and three additive conditions (Control, Pro, Post) was used.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Conservation agriculture plays an important role in the sustainability of production systems, notably for globally significant crops such as cotton. This study explores the integration of the no-tillage system (NTS) with integrated pest management (IPM) by incorporating cover crops. The aim is to assess the impact of these living or dead covers on the management of insect populations, the indices diversity of phytophagous insects and natural enemies, and to investigate the population fluctuation of these arthropods, considering a variety of crops in the NTS before and after cotton planting.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Geometry of milk liners affects milking performance in dairy cows.

J Dairy Res

September 2024

Faculty of Agriculture and Life Sciences, Lincoln University, Canterbury, New Zealand.

The geometry of milk liners may affect milking performance and cow comfort as the milk liner is the only part of the milking machine that comes into contact with the teat. To determine the effect of alternative shape of milk liners we compared square (SQR) the conventional round (RND) teat cup liner on milking performance and comfort of dairy cows. Treatment milk liners were randomly allocated to clusters within each side of the 12 a side double up-herringbone dairy shed in a complete randomised block design over two periods.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?

Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!