Correlation between modified Magee equation-2 and Oncotype-Dx recurrence scores using both traditional and TAILORx cutoffs and the clinical application of the Magee Decision Algorithm: a single institutional review.

Background: Oncotype Dx (ODX) is used to predict recurrence risk for estrogen-positive (ER +), HER2-negative and lymph node negative breast cancer, however, due to the cost its use may be limited in low-resource areas. The aim of this study is to assess the concordance between the modified Magee Equation-2 (MME-2) and ODX recurrence scores (RS). The secondary aim is to apply the Magee Decision Algorithm (MDA) using the MME-2 to determine which patients are unlikely to benefit from ODX testing.

Methods: All newly diagnosed ER + , HER2 negative, lymph node negative breast cancer patients with available ODX-RS from 2008-2018 were included. The original pathology reports were reviewed and chart review was performed. The MME-2 scores were calculated and correlated with the ODX-RS. The MDA was applied to our cohort to assess which patients would not benefit from ODX testing.

Results: A total of 579 patients were included. There was an overall moderate correlation between ODX-RS and MME-2 score (Pearson correlation coefficient = 0.635). The overall concordance between ODX and MME-2 scores was similar when using both the traditional and TAILORx cutoffs (63.3% vs. 63.7%, respectively). Applying the MDA, for patients with MME-2 scores < 18, 96.8% of patients had the expected ODX-RS of < 25. For patients with MME-2 RS > 30, 90% had the expected ODX-RS of > 25. Concordance was highest in the high-risk category using both cutoffs. For patients with MME-2 18-25 and a mitotic score of 1, 88.8% had the expected ODX-RS of > 25.

Conclusion: There is a moderate correlation between MME-2 score and ODX-RS. The overall concordance was similar for both traditional and TAILORx cutoffs. The strongest concordance was found in the high-risk category for both cutoffs. The MME-2 can be used to identify patients unlikely to benefit from ODX testing using the MDA.