AI Article Synopsis

  • The Bayesian statistical framework utilizes prior distributions to reflect pre-existing knowledge about parameter values, which significantly impact the results of analyses.
  • Prior elicitation is a method to derive these distributions based on expert input, but it involves several critical decisions that can influence the outcomes.
  • Researchers should carefully navigate the elicitation process, considering setup, the elicitation method, and how to combine inputs from different experts, as different choices can lead to varying priors from the same expert group.

Article Abstract

The Bayesian statistical framework requires the specification of prior distributions, which reflect predata knowledge about the relative plausibility of different parameter values. As prior distributions influence the results of Bayesian analyses, it is important to specify them with care. Prior elicitation has frequently been proposed as a principled method for deriving prior distributions based on expert knowledge. Although prior elicitation provides a theoretically satisfactory method of specifying prior distributions, there are several implicit decisions that researchers need to make at different stages of the elicitation process, each of them constituting important researcher degrees of freedom. Here, we discuss some of these decisions and group them into 3 categories: decisions about (a) the setup of the prior elicitation; (b) the core elicitation process; and (c) combination of elicited prior distributions from different experts. Importantly, different decision paths could result in greatly varying priors elicited from the same experts. Hence, researchers who wish to perform prior elicitation are advised to carefully consider each of the practical decisions before, during, and after the elicitation process. By explicitly outlining the consequences of these practical decisions, we hope to raise awareness for methodological flexibility in prior elicitation and provide researchers with a more structured approach to navigate the decision paths in prior elicitation. Making the decisions explicit also provides the foundation for further research that can identify evidence-based best practices that may eventually reduce the methodologically flexibility in prior elicitation. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/met0000354DOI Listing

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

prior elicitation
32
prior distributions
20
prior
13
flexibility prior
12
elicitation process
12
elicitation
11
methodological flexibility
8
decision paths
8
practical decisions
8
decisions
6

Similar Publications

Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?

Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!