Influence of experimental end point on the therapeutic efficacy of the antinicotinic compounds MB408, MB442 and MB444 in treating nerve agent poisoned mice - a comparison with oxime-based treatment.

Therapeutic efficacy of antidotal treatment of acute poisoning by nerve agents is generally assessed by the evaluation of LD values of nerve agents over 24 h following poisoning without or with a single administration of antidotal treatment. In this study, LD values of four nerve agents (sarin, soman, tabun and cyclosarin) for non-treated and treated poisoning were evaluated in mice for two experimental end points - 6 h and 24 h. While the efficacy of atropine or oxime-based antidotal treatment was the same regardless of the experimental end point, the therapeutic efficacy of all three newly developed bispyridinium non-oxime compounds (MB408, MB442, and MB444) was mostly slightly higher at the 6 h end point compared to the 24 h end point, although the therapeutic efficacy of MB compounds was not superior to oxime-based antidotal treatment. These results contrast with a study in guinea-pigs using a structurally-related compound, MB327, which showed a striking increase in protection at 6 h compared to 24 h. It is suggested that the disparity may be due to pharmacokinetic differences between the two animal species.