Tensioning device increases biomechanical stability of tuberosity fixation technique with cerclage sutures in reverse shoulder arthroplasty for fracture.

Background: Complex proximal humeral fractures in elderly patients are increasingly treated with primary reverse total shoulder arthroplasty. Many surgeons use cerclage sutures for tuberosity fixation in reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for proximal humeral fractures. In this study, we hypothesized that sutures fixated with a tensioning device would achieve higher initial fixation stability of the tuberosities compared with manually knotted cerclage sutures in a biomechanical model.

Methods: A 4-part fracture was created in 7-paired human cadaver proximal humeri. The tuberosities were reduced anatomically and fixed with 3 cerclage sutures in a standardized technique. Tightening was performed either manually (n = 7) or with a cerclage tensioning device with 50 Newton meter (N m) (n = 7). The humeri were placed in a custom-made test setup enabling internal and external rotation. Cyclic loading with gradually increasing load was applied with a material testing machine starting with 20 N m and increasing by 5 N m after each 100th cycle until failure (>15° rotation of the tuberosities). Motion of the tuberosities was measured with a 3-dimensional camera system.

Results: Overall, the knot group reached 1040 ± 152 cycles, and the device group reached 1820 ± 719 cycles (P = .035). Major fragment motion was detected in the humeral shaft axis and in the distal divergence of the tuberosities. After 900 cycles, the knot group showed increased rotation of both lesser and greater tuberosities in all 3 axes around the humeral shaft compared with the device group.

Conclusion: Biomechanical stability of the reattached tuberosities is significantly increased, and rotational movement of the tuberosities is decreased after tightening of the applied cerclage sutures with a tensioning device compared with manual knotting. However, transferability of these promising biomechanical results and their clinical relevance have to be verified with clinical studies.