Evidence of repeated horizontal transfer of sterol C-5 desaturase encoding genes among dikarya fungi.

Gene duplication and horizontal gene transfer (HGT) are two important but different forces for adaptive genome evolution. In eukaryotic organisms, gene duplication is considered to play a more important evolutionary role than HGT. However, certain fungal lineages have developed highly efficient mechanisms that avoid the occurrence of duplicated gene sequences within their genomes. While these mechanisms likely originated as a defense against harmful mobile genetic elements, they come with an evolutionary cost. A prominent example for a genome defense system is the RIP mechanism of the ascomycete fungus Neurospora crassa, which efficiently prevents sequence duplication within the genome and functional redundancy of the subsequent paralogs. Despite this tight control, the fungus possesses two functionally redundant sterol C-5 desaturase enzymes, ERG-10a and ERG-10b, that catalyze the same step during ergosterol biosynthesis. In this study, we addressed this conundrum by phylogenetic analysis of the two proteins and supporting topology tests. We obtained evidence that a primary HGT of a sterol C-5 desaturase gene from Tremellales (an order of Basidiomycota) into a representative of the Pezizomycotina (a subphylum of Ascomycota) is the origin of the ERG-10b sequence. The reconstructed phylogenies suggest that this HGT event was followed by multiple HGT events among other members of the Pezizomycotina, thereby generating a diverse group with members in the four classes Sordariomycetes, Xylonomycetes, Eurotiomycetes and Dothideomycetes, which all harbor the second sterol C-5 desaturase or maintained in some cases only the ERG-10b version of this enzyme. These results furnish an example for a gene present in numerous ascomycetous fungi but primarily acquired by an ancestral HGT event from another fungal phylum. Furthermore, these data indicate that HGT represents one mechanism to generate functional redundancy in organisms with a strict avoidance of gene duplications.