The N-terminal domains of the paralogous HycE and NuoCD govern assembly of the respective formate hydrogenlyase and NADH dehydrogenase complexes.

Formate hydrogenlyase (FHL) is the main hydrogen-producing enzyme complex in enterobacteria. It converts formate to CO and H via a formate dehydrogenase and a [NiFe]-hydrogenase. FHL and complex I are evolutionarily related and share a common core architecture. However, complex I catalyses the fundamentally different electron transfer from NADH to quinone and pumps protons. The catalytic FHL subunit, HycE, resembles NuoCD of Escherichia coli complex I; a fusion of NuoC and NuoD present in other organisms. The C-terminal domain of HycE harbours the [NiFe]-active site and is similar to other hydrogenases, while this domain in NuoCD is involved in quinone binding. The N-terminal domains of these proteins do not bind cofactors and are not involved in electron transfer. As these N-terminal domains are separate proteins in some organisms, we removed them in E. coli and observed that both FHL and complex I activities were essentially absent. This was due to either a disturbed assembly or to complex instability. Replacing the N-terminal domain of HycE with a 180 amino acid E. coli NuoC protein fusion did not restore activity, indicating that the domains have complex-specific functions. A FHL complex in which the N- and C-terminal domains of HycE were physically separated still retained most of its FHL activity, while the separation of NuoCD abolished complex I activity completely. Only the FHL complex tolerates physical separation of the HycE domains. Together, the findings strongly suggest that the N-terminal domains of these proteins are key determinants in complex assembly.