Community-engaged Evidence Synthesis to Inform Public Health Policy and Clinical Practice: A Case Study.

Background: This case study documents the work of the Rhode Island Arts and Health Advisory Group, which convened in 2016 to develop a set of policy, clinical practice, and research recommendations for implementation by the Rhode Island Department of Health, The Rhode Island State Council on the Arts, and partners. Comprised of artists, clinicians, community members, and patients, the group partnered with researchers to complete an evidence synthesis project of arts-based health care interventions.

Methods: The group took a community-engaged approach to evidence synthesis, featuring the use of online, and in-person training materials to facilitate the codesign and coexecution of the evidence synthesis protocol. The final evidence map was translated into an online evidence map to facilitate analysis and discussion on arts-based interventions in health care.

Results: The evidence map informed the development of recommendations for advancing the integration of arts and health in the state. The project evaluation indicated that our community-engaged approach to evidence synthesis promoted engagement as defined by the PCORI Engagement Strategy Rubric (ie, reciprocal relationships, partnership, colearning, transparency, honesty, and trust). Participation also improved community research partners confidence in engaging with the health care system, developed greater empathy and understanding of others in the community, and increased interest in using science or research in advocacy efforts.

Conclusions: Engaging community partners in evidence synthesis promotes community dialogue and engagement in research, specifically towards: (1) elucidating outcomes of import to patients and communities that are not represented in the medical literature; and (2) identifying comparisons among interventions that resonate with patients and communities.