Biology is undergoing a crisis whereby technical innovations designed to overcome the difficulties encountered in explaining complex biological phenomena have not delivered the expected results. To overcome this problem, mainstream biomedical researchers favor adopting new technological wonders without considering that what hinders their research could be due to their philosophical stance, theoretical frame, or looking into the wrong level of biological organization. We address the conceptual problems underlying the scientific crisis by examining the philosophical stances that have illuminated biological thought for the last 200 years and their evolution into the conceptual frames now known as reductionism and organicism. We also analyze how these stances seek to establish causality. The reductionist fixation on bottom-up causation is based on physicalism, a stance that does not allow for emergent phenomena. Organicism, by contrast, allows for emergence and asserts that biological entities are defined by the relation between what they are and what they do; thus, they generate novel qualities and structures. Also, only organisms experience illness and health. Organicism recognizes the role of agency and normativity in determining biological phenomena. Based on these premises, we favor adopting organicism to resolve the current crisis in the biomedical sciences.
Download full-text PDF |
Source |
|---|---|
| http://dx.doi.org/10.1353/pbm.2018.0059 | DOI Listing |
Publication Analysis
Top Keywords
Similar Publications
The Spemann-Mangold organizer discovery and society.
Cells Dev
June 2024
Rhine-Waal University of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Technology and Bionics, Marie-Curie-Straße 1, 47533 Kleve, Germany. Electronic address:
This paper analyzes the influence of Hans Spemann and Hilde Mangold's discovery of the embryonic organizer on society outside the narrower confines of embryology. It begins by overviewing how in the 1920s-1930s, the organizer discovery fit well into the agenda of both right-wing and left-wing political camps, as it supported holistic theories of biological development that aligned with their ideological views. The paper then explores the organizer's influence on the formation and interdisciplinary discussions of the 1930s Cambridge Theoretical Biology Club.
View Article and Find Full Text PDFThe third-way third wave and the enduring appeal of bioexceptionalism.
Theor Biol Forum
January 2022
The University of Alabama, 208 ten Hoor Hall, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487, USA, elpeterson
We may induce from a longue durée examination of Anglo-American History of Biology that the impulse to reject reduc - tionism persists and will continue to percolate cyclically. This impulse I deem "bioexceptionalism": an intuition, stance, attitude, or activating metaphor that the study of living beings requires explanations in addition to exclusively bottom-up causal explanations and the research programs constructed upon that bottom-up philosophical foundation by non-organismal biologists, biochemists, and biophysicists - the explanations, in other words, that Wadding - ton (1977) humorously termed the "Conventional Wisdom of the Dominant Group, or cowdung." Bioexceptionalism might indicate an ontological assertion, like vitalism.
View Article and Find Full Text PDFThe cancer puzzle: Welcome to organicism.
Prog Biophys Mol Biol
October 2021
Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts, USA; Centre Cavaillès, République des Savoirs, École Normale Supérieure, Paris, France. Electronic address:
During the fifty years since President Nixon declared the "War on Cancer", those inside and outside the cancer community have witnessed the systematic moving of the goalposts attitude to accommodate evidence into an inadequate theory, that is, the Somatic Mutation Theory (SMT). This sorry state promoted a renewable yearly promise that at the end of the next 10-year period the promises uttered in 1971 would become reality. Each failure triggered calls to do more of the same research under the same theory, routinely using more and more sophisticated technology.
View Article and Find Full Text PDFNeither superorganisms nor mere species aggregates: Charles Elton's sociological analogies and his moderate holism about ecological communities.
Hist Philos Life Sci
June 2020
Collège Lionel-Groulx, Sainte-Thérèse, QC, Canada.
This paper analyzes community ecologist Charles Elton's ideas on animal communities, and situates them with respect to the classical opposition between organicist-holistic and individualistic-reductionist ecological views drawn by many historians of ecology. It is argued that Elton espoused a moderate ecological holism, which drew a middle way between the stricter ecological holism advocated by organicist ecologists and the merely aggregationist views advocated by some of their opponents. It is also argued that Elton's moderate ecological holism resonated with his preference for analogies between ecological communities and human societies over more common ones between communities and individual organisms.
View Article and Find Full Text PDFReductionism, Organicism, and Causality in the Biomedical Sciences: A Critique.
Perspect Biol Med
January 2019
Biology is undergoing a crisis whereby technical innovations designed to overcome the difficulties encountered in explaining complex biological phenomena have not delivered the expected results. To overcome this problem, mainstream biomedical researchers favor adopting new technological wonders without considering that what hinders their research could be due to their philosophical stance, theoretical frame, or looking into the wrong level of biological organization. We address the conceptual problems underlying the scientific crisis by examining the philosophical stances that have illuminated biological thought for the last 200 years and their evolution into the conceptual frames now known as reductionism and organicism.
View Article and Find Full Text PDFWant AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?
Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!