What Is Caring in Nursing?: Sorting Out Humanistic and Christian Perspectives.

J Christ Nurs

R. Shirlene Newbanks, DNP, RN, is the assistant dean of the Masters in Administration and Education Programs in the School of Nursing at Indiana Wesleyan University (IWU), Marion, Indiana. She is active on the Caring from a Christian Worldview subcommittee of the International Institute of Christian Nursing (IICN) of Nurses Christian Fellowship International (NCFI). Linda S. Rieg, PhD, RN, has taught nursing in several nursing programs and is a professor in the School of Nursing graduate program at IWU. She has served as Director of the IICN of NCFI, and is active on the Caring from a Christian Worldview subcommittee of the Institute. Beverly Schaefer, EdD, RN, is the assistant dean of the Post-Licensure Division of Nursing at IWU.

Published: September 2019

Historically, some propose that organized nursing was founded on biblical principles and the caring behaviors and characteristics of Christ, and that caring originates with God. More recently, perceptions of caring have shifted to a humanistic, postmodern worldview, where the source of caring is within the person. This integrative literature review synthesized caring literature from humanistic, postmodern, and biblical, theological worldviews. Findings reveal that 95% of research and 85% of nonresearch publications were written from the humanistic perspective. The results lay a foundation for an alternative middle range theory on caring from a biblical worldview for nurses holding Christian beliefs.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/CNJ.0000000000000441DOI Listing

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

humanistic postmodern
8
caring
7
caring nursing?
4
nursing? sorting
4
humanistic
4
sorting humanistic
4
humanistic christian
4
christian perspectives
4
perspectives historically
4
historically propose
4

Similar Publications

Material and Spiritual Poverty: A Postmodern Psychological Perspective on a Perennial Problem.

J Relig Health

June 2020

Department of Psychology, University of West Georgia, 1601 Maple Street, Carrollton, GA, 30117, USA.

From a social-scientific perspective, this paper addresses an overlooked dimension of material poverty, namely spiritual poverty or the lack of spiritual sensitivity, and calls it a psychological disorder. Religions link deep spirituality with a kind of "poverty," namely simplicity of lifestyle and generosity toward the needy; but none advocates the poverty of outright destitution. A fully psychological "spiritualogy"-built on Bernard Lonergan's analysis of human consciousness or spirit and consonant with the humanistic psychology of Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow and current psychotherapeutic understanding-explains the link between spirituality and poverty as a matter of personal integration and suggests interventions to address the corrosive epidemic soul sickness of the postmodern world, so different from traditional societies in which religion and culture intertwined and functioned effectively.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

People with severe and profound grade disabilities are the subject of interest in psychiatry, clinical psychology and special pedagogy. Unfortunately, the paradigmatic approach to special education based on postmodern philosophy is in contrast to the biomedical approach that is based on the positivist and Cartesian models. The paper is an attempt to systematize the similarities and differences between the humanistic approach and the modern biomedical model, which, despite the apparent differences, do not differ so much from each other.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

What Is Caring in Nursing?: Sorting Out Humanistic and Christian Perspectives.

J Christ Nurs

September 2019

R. Shirlene Newbanks, DNP, RN, is the assistant dean of the Masters in Administration and Education Programs in the School of Nursing at Indiana Wesleyan University (IWU), Marion, Indiana. She is active on the Caring from a Christian Worldview subcommittee of the International Institute of Christian Nursing (IICN) of Nurses Christian Fellowship International (NCFI). Linda S. Rieg, PhD, RN, has taught nursing in several nursing programs and is a professor in the School of Nursing graduate program at IWU. She has served as Director of the IICN of NCFI, and is active on the Caring from a Christian Worldview subcommittee of the Institute. Beverly Schaefer, EdD, RN, is the assistant dean of the Post-Licensure Division of Nursing at IWU.

Historically, some propose that organized nursing was founded on biblical principles and the caring behaviors and characteristics of Christ, and that caring originates with God. More recently, perceptions of caring have shifted to a humanistic, postmodern worldview, where the source of caring is within the person. This integrative literature review synthesized caring literature from humanistic, postmodern, and biblical, theological worldviews.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Cultural initiation of medical doctors.

Coll Antropol

December 2013

Semmelweis University, Institute of Behavioral Sciences, Department of Medical Anthropology, Budapest, Hungary.

Eighteen years experience of teaching medical anthropology at a Hungarian medical school offers insight into the dynamics of interference between the rationalist epistemological tradition of biomedicine as one of the central paradigms of modernism and the cultural relativism of medical anthropology, as cultural anthropology is considered to be one of the generators of postmodern thinking. Tracing back the informal "prehistory" of our Institute, we can reveal its psychosomatic, humanistic commitment and critical basis as having represented a kind of counterculture compared with the technocrats of state-socialist Hungary's health ideology. The historical change and socio-cultural transition in Hungary after 1989 was accompanied by changes in the medical system as well as in philosophy and in the structure of the teaching of social sciences.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

This article describes a group for domestic violence survivors to help them move past a "liminal" state in which their social identity is characterized by being "victim" or "survivor" to one of "incorporation" defined by "thriving" and joy. Through the creation and use of healing rituals, blessings, poetry, art and music, the women in the group establish "communitas" and support each other in the work of self-reclamation and healing. The group, "Rites of Passage" is intended for women who have completed shelter-based crisis interventions, and uses a structured curriculum that integrates theoretical and philosophical concepts from anthropology, post-modernism, humanistic psychology, social work, and existentialism.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?

Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!