Global justice, capabilities approach and commercial surrogacy in India.

Med Health Care Philos

Cluster of Excellence, Asia and Europe in a Global Context, Karl Jaspers Centre for Advanced Transcultural Studies, Heidelberg University, Germany,

Published: August 2015

Inequalities, ineffective governance, unclear surrogacy regulations and unethical practices make India an ideal environment for global injustice in the process of commercial surrogacy. This article aims to apply the 'capabilities approach' to find possibilities of global justice through human fellowship in the context of commercial surrogacy. I draw primarily on my research findings supplemented by other relevant empirical research and documentary films on surrogacy. The paper reveals inequalities and inadequate basic entitlements among surrogate mothers as a consequence of which they are engaged in unjust contracts. Their limited entitlements also limit their opportunities to engage in enriching goals. It is the role of the state to provide all its citizens with basic entitlements and protect their basic human rights. Individuals in India evading their basic duty also contribute to the existing inequalities. Individual responsibilities of the medical practitioners and the intended parents are in question here as they are more inclined towards self-interest rather than commitment towards human fellowship. At the global level, the injustice in transnational commercial surrogacy practices in developing countries calls for an international declaration of women and child rights in third party reproduction with a normative vision of mutual fellowship and human dignity.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11019-015-9640-yDOI Listing

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

commercial surrogacy
16
global justice
8
human fellowship
8
basic entitlements
8
surrogacy
6
global
4
justice capabilities
4
capabilities approach
4
commercial
4
approach commercial
4

Similar Publications

Freshwater ecosystems are highly biodiverse and important for livelihoods and economic development, but are under substantial stress. To date, comprehensive global assessments of extinction risk have not included any speciose groups primarily living in freshwaters. Consequently, data from predominantly terrestrial tetrapods are used to guide environmental policy and conservation prioritization, whereas recent proposals for target setting in freshwaters use abiotic factors.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Objective: The increasing use of assisted reproductive technologies (ART) has led to a growing interest in the health outcomes of offspring. However, the impact of ART on the immune system of children remains poorly understood. While only two publications were found, their findings contradict each other and did not consider other risk factors in their analysis except for ART use.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF
Article Synopsis
  • The text discusses the evolution of the infertility industry in New York since the Baby M case, highlighting the rise of gestational carrier pregnancies and compensated surrogacy in various states due to advanced reproductive technologies.
  • It notes that the USA has become a popular destination for international couples seeking surrogacy, driven by strong medical care, available gestational carriers, and citizenship benefits for children born through these arrangements.
  • The author critiques the Child-Parent Security Act of 2021, pointing out the lack of strong regulations that protect gestational carriers and donor-conceived offspring, raising concerns about health risks, informed consent, and the market-driven nature of compensated surrogacy.
View Article and Find Full Text PDF

In response to the changing landscape of transnational surrogacy, the industry has introduced flexible business models requiring women to move within and across borders to act as surrogate mothers. However, knowledge about their experiences remain vague, particularly concerning women traveling abroad under illegal conditions. Building upon interviews with Thai surrogate mothers, I demonstrate how their im/mobility reveals critical insights into labor conditions and power relations and is formed within the global reproductive industry as well as the specific national context.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Navigating the gestational surrogacy seas: the legalities and complexities of gestational carrier services.

J Assist Reprod Genet

November 2024

Division of Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Stanford School of Medicine, Stanford, CA, USA.

This paper offers a comprehensive review of the gestational surrogacy process in the US, as well as internationally, focusing on the legal and ethical challenges that gestational carriers, intended parents, fertility providers, and OB/GYNs may face. The objective of this review article is to serve as an overview and provide information on legal, cultural, and ethical aspects of the decisions to pursue gestational surrogacy both for intended parents and gestational carriers in the US and globally. By understanding the surrogacy landscape and the obstacles, the surrogacy agencies and other involved parties can improve the surrogacy process to better serve all parties involved.

View Article and Find Full Text PDF

Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?

Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!