How many digits should be reported in forensic breath alcohol measurements?

J Anal Toxicol

Clearview Statistical Consulting, 20119 61st Avenue SE, Snohomish, WA 98296, USA

Published: June 2015

AI Article Synopsis

  • Uncertainty is a natural part of all measurements, and its size affects how many significant digits should be included in reporting results.
  • Statistical analysis suggests that truncating results to three digits is more accurate than two digits because the first significant digit of uncertainty appears in the third decimal place for breath alcohol measurements.
  • For example, using three digits reduces combined uncertainty from approximately 0.0042 g/210 L (two digits) to 0.0031 g/210 L, highlighting a need to update reporting practices in forensic breath alcohol analysis, especially with modern digital instruments.

Article Abstract

Uncertainty is an inherent property of all measurements. The magnitude of this uncertainty will determine the number of meaningful digits that should be reported in a measurement result. Several statistical arguments are considered providing evidence that three digit truncated results are more appropriate than two since the first significant digit of the combined uncertainty (standard deviation) in breath alcohol measurement is found in the third decimal place. Probably, the most compelling reason for reporting three digits is the significant reduction in combined uncertainty compared with the use of two digits. For a breath alcohol concentration of 0.089 g/210 L, the combined uncertainty for two digit results is ∼0.0042 g/210 L, compared with 0.0031 g/210 L for three digit results. The historical practice of reporting two digit truncated results in forensic breath alcohol analysis has been largely based on the use of analog scale instruments with 0.01 g/210 L scale resolution. With today's modern digital instrumentation, this practice should be reconsidered. While the focus of this paper is on breath alcohol analysis, the general principles will apply to any quantitative analytical measurement.

Download full-text PDF

Source
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jat/bkv025DOI Listing

Publication Analysis

Top Keywords

breath alcohol
20
combined uncertainty
12
digits reported
8
forensic breath
8
three digit
8
digit truncated
8
alcohol analysis
8
breath
5
alcohol
5
uncertainty
5

Similar Publications

Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?

Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!