Background: More than half of all Canadian medical graduates match to residency programs within the same university as their medical school. Here we describe two studies designed to explore whether there is partiality for internal applicants in the resident selection process.
Methods: We first performed an observational study in which we compared the ratings of 14 'internal' and 89 'external' applicants to the University of Calgary Internal Medicine Training Program by resident and faculty raters. Following this we then asked residents to rate anonymous application packages in which we manipulated applicants' affiliation to our training program.
Results: In our first study, we found that residents rated internal applicants significantly higher for both application packages (mean (SD)) rating for internal versus external applicants (4.86 (0.36) vs. 4.36 (0.57), d = 1.05, p = 0.002) and interviews (4.93 (0.27) vs. 4.36 (0.7), d = 1.07, p = 0.003). There was no difference in the faculty ratings of internal and external applicants. In our second study, we found that residents rated applicants with an affiliation to our program - either attending the local medical school or having completed an elective - higher than applicants with no affiliation to our program.
Conclusions: Our finding support in-group bias during resident selection, possibly due to the interdependent relationship between residents and students. Considering the career implications of residency matching, we feel that further studies are needed to identify and mitigate sources of bias in the residency application process.
Download full-text PDF |
Source |
|---|---|
| http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2013.801937 | DOI Listing |
Publication Analysis
Top Keywords
Similar Publications
Peer Status Influences In-Group Favoritism in Pain Empathy During Middle Childhood: Evidence from Behavioral and Event-Related Potentials Studies.
Brain Sci
December 2024
Faculty of Psychology, Tianjin Normal University, Tianjin 300387, China.
Background/objectives: Empathy for pain enhances our ability to perceive pain and recognize potential dangers. Empathic bias occurs when members of the in-group evoke more intense empathic responses compared to out-group members. In the process of interacting with peers, children develop peer status and spontaneously form peer groups.
View Article and Find Full Text PDFImplementing Holistic Applicant Review and Addressing Biases in Anesthesiology Residency Committee Deliberations.
A A Pract
December 2024
From the Department of Anesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California.
Background: Holistic review of applications may optimize recruitment of residents by seeking out characteristics best aligned with program culture. The goals of this mixed methods research were to engage residency recruitment stakeholders to develop a holistic scoring rubric, measure the correlation between the rubric score and the final global rating used to rank applicants for the National Resident Matching Program Match, and qualitatively analyze committee discussions at the end of the interview day about applicants for potential unconscious biases.
Methods: Forty stakeholders (32 faculty, 3 chief residents, and 5 administrative staff) completed an iterative consensus-driven process to identify the most highly valued applicant attributes, and a corresponding standardized question for each attribute.
Article Synopsis
- ADHD symptoms can continue into adulthood, affecting areas like executive function, emotional regulation, and motivation, yet there's limited research on effective treatment options such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) in Japan.
- This study aims to evaluate a new, culturally-adapted CBT program for adult ADHD patients in Japan, involving 12 participants in an open, multicenter format over a period of 24-28 weeks.
- The main focus will be on assessing the feasibility of this CBT program through dropout rates and clinical severity score changes, while also examining long-term treatment effects and related factors like depression and quality of life.
The Effect of Temporary Group Identity on Adolescent Social Mindfulness Decisions: An Empirical Study Using Team Sports Contexts.
Behav Sci (Basel)
October 2024
College of Physical Education, Yangzhou University, Yangzhou 225000, China.
Article Synopsis
- Social mindfulness involves being aware of others' needs while respecting their freedom, but this study focuses on how temporary group identities may influence this behavior.
- Researchers studied 74 adolescents in a basketball club, assigning them to either in-group or out-group scenarios to observe their decision-making.
- Results indicated that adolescents displayed greater social mindfulness and positive bias towards their in-group, while showing increased social hostility towards out-group members, highlighting the impact of temporary group identities on social behavior.
The Safety of Spinal Surgery in Patients over 80 Years of Age: Propensity Score Matching Study.
Global Spine J
November 2024
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Seoul St. Mary's Hospital, College of Medicine, The Catholic University of Korea, Seoul, Korea.
Article Synopsis
- The study is a retrospective cohort analysis that uses propensity score matching to compare clinical outcomes and complications in octogenarians (80+) and elderly patients (65-79) who underwent spinal surgery at a single hospital in Korea.
- After matching, both groups comprised 49 patients each, revealing no significant differences in pain or disability outcomes, but a longer follow-up period and more medical complications, particularly delirium, in the octogenarian group.
- The findings suggest that while older patients may face higher complication rates, age alone shouldn't deter clinicians from performing spinal surgery in this population, especially with proper delirium prevention strategies in place.
Want AI Summaries of new PubMed Abstracts delivered to your In-box?
Enter search terms and have AI summaries delivered each week - change queries or unsubscribe any time!