Influence of anion on the quadratic nonlinearity and depolarization ratios of scattered second harmonic light from cation-π complexes.

We have investigated quadratic nonlinearity (β(HRS)) and linear and circular depolarization ratios (D and D('), respectively) of a series of 1:1 complexes of tropyliumtetrafluoroborate as a cation and methyl-substituted benzenes as π-donors by making polarization resolved hyper-Rayleigh scattering measurements in solution. The measured D and D(') values are much lower than the values expected from a typical sandwich or a T-shaped geometry of a complex. In the cation-π complexes studied here, the D value varies from 1.36 to 1.46 and D(') from 1.62 to 1.72 depending on the number of methyl substitutions on the benzene ring. In order to probe it further, β, D and D(') were computed using the Zerner intermediate neglect of differential overlap-correction vector self-consistent reaction field technique including single and double configuration interactions in the absence and presence of BF(4) (-) anion. In the absence of the anion, the calculated value of D varies from 4.20 to 4.60 and that of D(') from 2.45 to 2.72 which disagree with experimental values. However, by arranging three cation-π BF(4)(-) complexes in a trigonal symmetry, the computed values are brought to agreement with experiments. When such an arrangement was not considered, the calculated β values were lower than the experimental values by more than a factor of two. This unprecedented influence of the otherwise "unimportant" anion in solution on the β value and depolarization ratios of these cation-π complexes is highlighted and emphasized in this paper.