Effects of deflection and archwire dimension on the mechanical performance of two self-ligating orthodontic systems.

Objectives: To analyze the effects of archwire deflection and dimension on the mechanical performance of two self-ligating systems, as passive and active ligation designs.

Materials And Methods: An experimental model was used that was designed to resemble the full dental arch and to allow vertical displacement of a canine element. Two self-ligating systems were investigated: 1) a passive system; and 2) an active system, both in combination with three thermoactive NiTi archwires, with round sections of 0.014-in, 0.016-in and 0.018-in. The full loading-unloading cycles consisted of either 3mm or 6mm maximum deflection, performed at 37 °C. During unloading, the deactivation forces and energy were recorded. The ratio between the deactivation and activation energies was used as representative of the mechanical efficiencies of the systems.

Results: The deactivation force increased in combination with larger archwires and greater deflection. The deactivation energy increased in combination with larger archwires only for the 3-mm deflection cycle, while for the 6-mm deflection cycle, the deactivation energy was not influenced by the archwire dimension, and was not greater than that of the 3-mm deflection cycle. The mechanical efficiency decreased in combination with greater deflection and larger archwires, with a maximum decrease of about 12%. Only minor comparative differences were seen between the systems.

Conclusions: The deflection degree and archwire dimension have large effects on the mechanical performance of self-ligating systems.