Does surgical experience have an effect on the success of retinal detachment surgery?

Purpose: To examine the relationship between surgeon experience and success rates in retinal detachment surgery.

Methods: Success rates during a follow-up of 11 months of 8 surgeons who performed in total 375 retinal detachment procedures ranging from 14 to 115 cases between December 1997 and January 2002 were correlated to the total number of vitreoretinal procedures ranging between 176 and 2,587. All patients received either scleral buckling or vitrectomy, and complicated cases were excluded.

Results: Mean primary anatomical success rates were 0.69 ± 0.14 for scleral buckling and 0.9 ± 0.05 for primary vitrectomy (P < 0.05). The primary anatomical success rates did not correlate to the number of vitreoretinal procedures. Seven of the eight surgeons showed an intraindividual learning effect with better success rates in the second versus the first half of the observed procedures. The learning effect was correlated to the total number of procedures with a higher effect in inexperienced surgeons.

Conclusion: An intraindividual learning effect that was higher in inexperienced surgeons could be demonstrated. The learning effect was reduced by half after 500 vitreoretinal procedures while the primary anatomical success rates were not correlated to the number of vitreoretinal procedures.