Comparative evaluation of two techniques of hemostasis in neonatal circumcision using the Plastibell device.

Objective: To evaluate the safety of the Plastibell neonatal circumcision technique and the incidence of complications in Iranian neonates.

Materials & Methods: In this study, 7510 term neonates born between 2001 and 2006 in Rafsanjan medical centers, with age range of 3-36h, were randomized into two groups. In group A (3760 cases), an incision was made in the dorsal surface of the prepuce and then 3min frenular manual compression was performed with a sponge. In group B (3750 cases), frenular hemostasis was achieved using ophthalmologic thermal cautery. The two groups were compared in terms of complications of hemorrhage, wound infection, urine retention and delayed wound healing.

Results: In group A, bleeding occurred in 15 cases (0.4%), and in group B in two cases (0.05%). The bleeding rate in group A was significantly higher (P=0.002). In group A, urinary retention was seen in 12 cases (0.03%), in comparison to 35 cases (0.9%) in group B. This complication rate was significantly higher in group B (P=0.001). Local or systemic infection was not seen in either group.

Conclusion: Although using thermal cautery we have less bleeding, the total complication rate is increased significantly.