Systematic review of high dose chemotherapy and autologous haematopoietic stem cell transplantation for chronic lymphocytic leukaemia: what is the published evidence?

Despite improved responses, chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) remains incurable with conventional chemotherapy. Patients with poor-risk factors or who fail conventional chemoimmunotherapy are offered autografts, preferably after achieving remission. This report presents the totality of evidence through a systematic review that assessed the efficacy of autografts in CLL. A search of MEDLINE databases from 1966-2006 and hand-search of references identified 82 prospective-randomized, non-randomized comparisons or single-arm trials, of which only nine met our inclusion criteria: two trials were funded by public/government, one by private foundations, one jointly by private/public, and was unclear in five. No randomized controlled trials comparing autografts versus conventional chemotherapy (or chemoimmunotherapy) were found. Six studies were single-arm and three were non-randomized with a control-arm (autologous versus allogeneic). Overall, 361 patients were enrolled, but only 292 were transplanted. Transplant-related mortality ranged from 0% to 9%. Complete responses ranged from 74% to 100% and molecular responses ranged from 57% to 88%. Overall survival ranged from 68% at 3 years to 58% at 6 years. It is uncertain whether autograft is superior to conventional therapy. The high incidence of myelodysplastic syndrome (9-12%) is particularly concerning in CLL, where median survival is 9 years.