Variation of atomic charges on proton transfer in strong hydrogen bonds: the case of anionic and neutral imidazole-acetate complexes.

The variation of atomic charges upon proton transfer in hydrogen bonding complexes of 4-methylimidazole, in both neutral and protonated cationic forms, and acetate anion, is investigated. These complexes model the histidine (neutral and protonated)-aspartate pair present in active sites of proteases where strong N--H...O hydrogen bonds are formed. Three procedures (Merz-Kollman scheme, Natural Population Analysis, and Atoms in Molecules Method) are used to compute atomic charges and explore their variation upon H-transfer in the gas phase and in the presence of two continuum media with dielectric constants 5 (protein interiors) and 78.39 (water). The effect of electron correlation was also studied by comparing Hartree-Fock and MP2 results for both complexes in the gas phase. Greater net charge interchanged upon H-transfer is observed in the anionic complex with respect to the neutral complex. Raising the polarity of the medium increases the amount of net charge transfer in both complexes, although the neutral system exhibits a larger sensitivity to the presence of solvent. Charge transfer associated to N--H...O and N...H--O bonds reveal the ionic contribution to the interaction depending on the number of charged subunits but the presence of solvent affects little this quantity. The lack of electron correlation overestimates all the charges as well as their variations and so uncorrelated calculations should be avoided.