Leakage flow at mechanical heart valve prostheses: improved washout or increased blood damage?

Background And Aims Of The Study: An essential problem of mechanical heart valve (MHV) prostheses is the risk of thromboembolic events and consequent need of lifetime anticoagulation due to unnatural hemodynamics that results in traumatization of red blood cells and platelets. The precise spatial and tidal localization of blood-damaging events within the flow is poorly understood. The present study addresses the question whether leakage flow at MHV, which is claimed to improve washout in the hinge areas of microthrombi and platelet-activating agents, is responsible for significant blood damage.

Methods: This study investigated leakage flow in vitro, primarily within turbulent leakage jets of currently used mechanical valves. St. Jude Medical, Sorin Bicarbon, Duromedics-Edwards and CarboMedics valves were analyzed in the mitral position of a circulatory mock loop. Jet configuration was determined by echocardiography; velocity and shear stress distributions within jets were measured using laser-Doppler anemometry (LDA). A blood damage index (BDI) was developed in terms of lactate dehydrogenase release by platelets and hemoglobin release by red blood cells (RBC), as a function of exposure time and shear stresses within the flow field. BDIs were validated by direct measurement of hemolysis caused by leakage flow, using porcine blood.

Results: All valves showed characteristic and reproducible jet patterns, mainly emerging from the hinge areas. Maximum velocities up to 1.7 m/s were measured. Maximum turbulent shear stresses > 80 Pa were found. The investigated MHV revealed significant differences in calculated BDIs. The Sorin Bicarbon had a significantly lower BDI for RBC damage, as well as for platelet damage; this was validated by direct hemolysis measurements.

Conclusions: The relevance of the leakage-induced blood damage was demonstrated from a literature investigation of hemolysis as a function of valve type and implant position.