Organizing mental health services: an evidence-based approach.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Health policy makers and program developers seek evidence-based guidance on how to organize and finance mental health services. The Swedish Council on Technology Assessment in Health Care (SBU) commissioned a conceptual framework for thinking about health care services as a medical technology. The following framework was developed, citing empirical research from mental health services research as the case example.

[Conflicting values in evaluation of psychiatric care--a review].

Greater understanding is needed regarding psychiatric disorders and their causes, as well as the effects of psychiatric care. Ethical issues ought to be discussed in terms of both the choice of questions and to the ways in which data are collected. So far, most evaluations of psychiatric care have focused on medical utility, while issues of autonomy and impartiality are sorely lacking.

Psychiatric ethics and health services research. Concepts and research strategies.

In a conceptual frame of reference a distinction is made between different aspects of coercion (formal, perceived and evaluated) and different levels of coercion (hospitalization, treatment and other measures). This frame of reference is used to analyse empirical data from interviews of representative samples of 100 formally committed, the 'probands', and 99 voluntarily admitted sex- and age-matched 'controls'. The results demonstrate that there are many different aspects of coercion; thus, discussions about psychiatric coercion should not be restricted to formally registered commitment.

Values and technology assessment in psychiatry.

Economic resources for health care are limited and they should be distributed as fairly and effectively as possible. But the basis for such a distribution is far from clear. What interests are involved? What kind of provision of care is most efficient? How far should the distribution be left to market solutions? What is the proper role of health care politicians and authorities? In technology assessment a promising combination of value premises and empirical knowledge is used in answering such questions.

Coercive measures in psychiatric care. Reports and reactions of patients and other people involved.

In ongoing studies of the quality of the mental health services in two Swedish counties, two thirds of the committed versus about one third of the voluntarily admitted patients reported coercive measures during the index period of care. Committed patients reported an equal degree of coercive treatment and restraint, whereas restraint dominated among the voluntarily admitted. The majority of the patients described the coercive measures as implemented by fait accompli; force was reported in 23% of the examples given by the committed patients but never by the voluntarily admitted.

The ethics of data utilisation: a comparison between epidemiology and journalism.

Legal controls over data collection in European countries have badly affected the work of epidemiologists. By contrast, journalists have been allowed far greater freedoms. The aims and tasks of both professions are in line with accepted values in our society--especially those of inquiry and the benefits of an open society.

Epidemiology and moral philosophy.

To an increasing extent ethical controversies affect and sometimes obstruct public health work and epidemiological research. In order to improve communication between the concerned parties a model for identification and analysis of ethical conflicts in individual-based research has been worked out in co-operation between epidemiologists and moral philosophers. The model has two dimensions.

Longitudinal studies on environmental factors and disease. A model for analysis of ethical conflicts.

The use of individual-based data in research has recently come in for much discussion. The basic issue of the discussion is how to balance between different legitimate interests: the interest in improving knowledge on matters important to human health and the interest in respecting individual autonomy. In this paper we will use a model for description and analysis of ethical conflicts in individual-based research.

Strategies implemented but goals not attained. Some comments on an evaluation of the Swedish mental health services.

Is the development of Swedish psychiatry a success or not? Available information allows different answers to this question. Valid knowledge would demand psychiatric health service research on a much larger scale and with considerably higher ambitions than hitherto. Strong arguments can be raised about the need for such research to avoid that psychiatry will remain a medical wasteland in which confused policy makers will allocate less interest and money than ever.